Skip to main content
"Long hair cut in salon"
"Jada Pinkett Smith at the Performing Arts Center event"
"Kim Kardashian at the Academy Museum Gala"

Food

5 ‘Healthy’ Snacks That Are Actually Packed With Sugar And Fueling Weight Gain, Experts Say

October 16, 2025 by Faith Geiger
shefinds | Food
Featured image

Some snacks that seem like a smart choice for your waistline are secretly packed with sugar—which we all know can lead to a lot of health risks over time. Unfortunately, many options that seem healthy on the surface (and are even marketed as such) can spike your blood sugar, increase cravings, and even lead to unwanted weight gain over time.

We spoke to Kathleen McDermott, MSN, RN, Certified Women’s Health Coach to get a low-down on some of the most deceiving options on grocery store shelves. From flavored yogurts to store-bought granola, these sneaky snacks may be derailing your healthy eating goals: granola, muffins, yogurt, trail mix, and even peanut butter. Learn more about the risks of each below.

house unit img
The Difference Between Dragging Through Your Day And Feeling Great On Your Feet? These Arch Support Insoles
granola at grocery store

1. Sugary Granola

We love a crunchy parfait packed with granola as much as the next person, but it's important to be mindful of the type of granola you're adding to the mix if you're watching your weight. While granola (like trail mix) boasts nutritious ingredients like nuts, oats, and seeds, store-bought options often contain a significant amount of added sugar. "Make your own toasted oats, coconut, nuts, and seeds granola; after toasting, add craisins and dark chocolate for some sweetness," McDermott recommends as an alternative to pre-packaged varieties.

bran muffins

2. Bran Muffins

If you're craving something carby and sweet for breakfast, bran muffins could sound like the perfect healthy compromise, especially when compared to choices like sugary pastries and donuts. Unfortunately, while bran itself is nutritious, it loses its health benefits when combined with high levels of sugar and fat in muffin form. McDermott recommends substituting sugar with applesauce and honey in bran muffin recipes to reduce inflammation and promote weight loss.

yogurt at grocery store

3. Sweetened Yogurt

When you eat the right type of yogurt, it can be a perfect healthy snack or breakfast. However, while it may be tempting to choose flavored options, these can take a toll on your health, potentially resulting in inflammation and weight gain. "Many average-sized cups of flavored yogurt have 30 grams of sugar, equivalent to 7.5 teaspoons. Many chocolate bars have the same amount of sugar!" McDermott tells us. She advises opting for plain Greek yogurt (which is packed with benefits!) instead, and adding natural sweeteners like honey, nuts, and fresh berries. Sounds perfect!

trail mix

4. Trail Mix

Trail mix is considered one of the healthiest snacks around—and in some cases, this is accurate. However, it all depends on the type of trail mix you choose. "Many packaged types of trail mix have a high amount of added sugar and sodium, which can contribute to inflammation and weight gain," McDermott warns. To avoid overconsumption, she advises, "Measure out a portion and put the bag away. Or make your own toasted oats, coconut, nuts, and seeds granola; after toasting, add craisins and dark chocolate for some sweetness." Yum!

peanut butter

5. Some Peanut Butters

Who can resist some good old PB&J? Don't fret; there are certainly healthy peanut butters out there. Plus, when paired with apples, it makes a classic, healthy snack. However, McDermott gives a word of caution against certain varieties: "Peanut butter, while delicious, can easily become a high-calorie, weight-gain food," she says. She advises opting for all-natural peanut butter without added salt, sugar, or vegetable oil and being mindful of portion sizes. Got it!

Author:

Freelance Writer

Faith Geiger is a New York-based writer and editor. When she's not covering the latest in health and wellness for SheFinds, she spends her time watching reality TV with her roommates, browsing used bookstores, and enjoying live music. You can reach Faith at faithkgeiger@gmail.com.

"Fit woman eating avocado, cucumber, tomatoes, and walnuts"
"Cottage cheese with berries"
"Various types of yogurt and processed meats"
"Stracciatella dipped cookie sandwiches from Aldi"
"Pan-fried salmon served with kale"
"Black bean taco salad bowl"
"Woman snacking on chips"
"Leafy greens, eggs, steak, and a woman with hair loss"
"Person checking blood sugar level"
"Gwyneth Paltrow at The Fashion Awards"
"Walmart store"
"Food dyes in packaging"
"Person grabbing an avocado while shopping"
"Woman stepping onto scale"
"Straw tote with Magic Spoon protein treats from Aldi"
"Person drinking soda"
"Woman walking on treadmill"
"High-protein breakfast plate"
"Woman holding a donut"
"Scrambled eggs breakfast with sausage and tomato"
Fit woman savoring a nutritious meal with avocados and walnuts.
Cottage cheese topped with fresh berries for a healthy snack.
Best yogurt options and worst processed meats comparison.
Stracciatella dipped cookie sandwiches from Aldi's dessert selection.
Pan-fried salmon served with kale on a plate.
Black bean taco salad bowl loaded with fresh vegetables.
Woman snacking on chips for a quick bite.
Woman enjoying a healthy meal with leafy greens, eggs, and steak.
Checking blood sugar levels for health monitoring.
Gwyneth Paltrow at The Fashion Awards looking stylish.
Walmart store aisle showcasing various products.
Colorful food dyes displayed for baking and cooking.
Shopper selecting an avocado for healthy meals.
Woman stepping onto a scale for weight tracking.
Straw tote with Magic Spoon protein treats from Aldi.
Person drinking soda at a casual gathering.
Woman exercising on a treadmill for fitness and beauty.
High-protein breakfast bowl with eggs and toppings.
Woman enjoying a colorful donut treat.
Scrambled eggs with sausage and tomatoes on a plate.